Earth & Space Science Regents Labs: Are Students Really Getting the Science?
If you're teaching Earth & Space Science in good old New York State, you know there's a lot of curriculum to get through. Between the required state investigations, the Regents, and the new Earth and Space Sciences Reference Tables, we've certainly got our work cut out for us.
And I'll say something that might surprise a few people: I'm actually pretty pleased with the direction New York State has taken.
The emphasis on scientific practices, developing and using models, analyzing evidence, and constructing explanations is exactly the kind of science instruction I believe in.
But there's a question I keep coming back to.
How do we know our students are actually understanding the science, rather than simply getting really good at performing the tasks we put in front of them?
Take the new Earth and Space Sciences Reference Tables, for example. Students need to know how to use those diagrams, graphs, and models. Absolutely. But a student who can correctly interpret the H–R diagram to answer a Regents question doesn't necessarily understand why stars form those patterns in the first place.
The same goes for identifying plate boundaries on a map or drawing lines to locate Mars. Being able to use a scientific representation is an important skill. But understanding the science behind that representation is where things get interesting.
And that's the part I don't want us to lose while we're busy making sure we've covered everything.
So I've been thinking a lot about what students need before, during, and after our required investigations and other curriculum activities to make sure that understanding is actually developing.
Here are four Earth & Space Science investigations I've designed to get at the science underneath the procedures, diagrams, and vocabulary.
1. Groundwater & Porosity: Connecting the State Lab to a Bigger System
New York State's required Ripple Effect investigation gives students an opportunity to investigate how water interacts with Earth materials and affects surface processes. But I also want students to take that reasoning further and consider how those interactions connect to the larger groundwater system.
That's where my groundwater investigation comes in. The problem begins with a town experiencing two seemingly contradictory issues: flooded streets and declining well water levels.
How can a town have too much water in one place and not enough in another?

Students may already know about porosity, permeability, infiltration, and runoff. But knowing those concepts individually isn't quite the same as being able to use them together to explain what's happening in an interconnected system.
Rather than moving through a series of isolated activities, students begin with the town's problem and construct an initial model. They then gather evidence through demonstrations, data, and a groundwater simulation before returning to revise their explanations.
What I'm after is the connection between the evidence students collect and the processes responsible for what they're observing.
This makes a natural extension of the thinking emphasized in The Ripple Effect. The state investigation addresses water's interactions with Earth materials and surface processes; the groundwater mystery gives students another context in which to apply and connect their understanding of water movement.
My Groundwater Inquiry Lab: Flooded Streets & Dry Wells is built around that mystery, with modeling, evidence collection, discussion, and opportunities to revise student thinking.
Something worth trying: After investigating water's effects on Earth materials, challenge students to explain how a change at the surface could affect what happens underground. Can they use evidence to connect the processes, rather than simply naming them?
2. Unearthing Mars: Before Students Start Playing Celestial Connect-the-Dots
Of the three NYS-required investigations, Unearthing Mars is one where I think what happens before students begin the lab can make an enormous difference.
There's a lot going on. Students are working with angles, lines of sight, orbital positions, and geometric representations of something they can't directly observe from above.
And it's entirely possible to get pretty good at following those procedures without understanding what the measurements actually represent. They know where to draw the line. But do they know why?

That's what I wanted to address before students encounter the official investigation.
My approach begins with something students can visualize: locating an object using observations from different positions. Before we start tackling planetary motion, I want them to understand what an observation tells us, what it doesn't tell us, and why another observation might be necessary.
Then we move toward the astronomical representations.
My Unearthing Mars Regents State Lab Pre-Lab gives students two periods of preparation through demonstrations, scaled models, geometric reasoning, and the historical observations that eventually helped reshape our understanding of planetary motion.
It's not about getting a head start on filling in the state lab packet. It's about building the understanding students need so that the state lab makes sense when they get there.
Something worth trying: Before students draw another line, ask them what that line represents and why they need it. You might discover they understand the procedure beautifully but aren't quite sure what the procedure is accomplishing.
3. H–R Diagram: Understanding the Model Before Learning to Use It
Ah, the H–R diagram. The new Earth and Space Sciences Reference Tables give students this incredibly useful representation of stellar properties. And of course we want them to know how to use it. They should be comfortable locating stars, comparing luminosities and temperatures, and recognizing the different regions.
But I don't want their understanding of stars to begin and end with being able to read the chart correctly. I want them to understand why those patterns exist. So rather than beginning with the completed H–R diagram, my investigation starts with a different question:
Do stars that look alike actually work alike?
Students begin by examining star cards and developing their own classification systems based on observable characteristics. Then they're introduced to evidence about what's happening inside those stars.
And now some of their original groupings aren't quite so convincing. That's intentional. Students have a reason to rethink their classifications, consider the relationship between appearance and internal processes, and look for a better way to organize the evidence. Only then do we bring in the H–R diagram.
My H–R Diagram Inquiry Lab: Star Classification & Fusion follows this progression through card sorting, model building, discussion, and application questions.
Instead of handing students a scientific model and teaching them how to use it, we're creating a reason for them to need that model in the first place.
Something worth trying: Before introducing the H–R diagram, have students sort a few stars based on their observable characteristics. Then introduce information about what's happening inside those stars. Do their original groupings still make sense? What would they change, and why?
4. Seafloor Spreading: From Recognizing a Pattern to Explaining It
The reference tables give students useful models and maps of Earth's interior and tectonic activity. We absolutely need students to understand how to interpret them. But I also want to know whether they understand the processes responsible for what those representations show.
For seafloor spreading, I like beginning with a problem that students can't solve simply by identifying a plate boundary or recalling a definition.
If Earth is billions of years old, why is the oldest existing oceanic crust only about 200 million years old?

It's a great geological mystery because students have to connect several ideas before they can build a convincing explanation.
They might recognize the age patterns on the ocean floor. They might know where new crust forms. But can they explain how those patterns develop and why much older oceanic crust isn't still around?
That's the reasoning I want to uncover.
My Seafloor Spreading Lab: Ocean Crust Age & Plate Tectonics Inquiry begins with that mystery and uses seafloor-age evidence and a tectonic simulation to help students develop an explanation of crust formation, movement, and recycling.
Students aren't just being asked to identify patterns. They're being challenged to explain the mechanisms that produce them.
Something worth trying: Show students an ocean-floor age map and ask them what needs explaining. Rather than telling them which pattern to notice, let the evidence create the questions that drive the investigation.
Getting Through the Curriculum vs. Getting to the Science
I really am encouraged by the direction of New York State's Earth & Space Science curriculum. I like that we're asking students to work with evidence, develop models, and explain phenomena rather than simply memorize information.
But I think we have to be careful not to turn those same scientific practices into another set of procedures students learn to perform.
A student can become very efficient at completing a model without understanding what the model represents. They can read a reference-table diagram accurately without understanding the evidence or reasoning behind it. And they can finish a required investigation without being able to apply that understanding in a new situation.
That doesn't mean those skills aren't valuable. They absolutely are.
It means we need to make sure we're giving students opportunities to go beyond them.
And I'm certainly not suggesting we all need to cram another dozen investigations into an already-packed school year. Sometimes it's an additional experience before a major lab. Sometimes it's presenting familiar science through an unfamiliar problem. And sometimes it's as simple as changing the questions we ask.
Instead of asking students to identify a pattern, ask them to explain what might be producing it. Instead of asking them to complete a model, ask what evidence would make them revise it. Instead of asking whether they got the correct answer, ask whether they could defend that answer using what they've figured out.
For me, that's the real promise of the direction we're moving in with Earth & Space Science.
I don't just want students who can successfully complete a Regents lab or read a reference-table diagram. I want students who understand the science well enough to explain it, question it, and use it somewhere new.
Because that's when we know we're doing more than just covering the curriculum.



Comments